Sparton Resources (TSX-SRI-V), (“the Company”), is pleased to report today that the US Department of Energy (“DOE”) has, after an extensive study, selected flow batteries as the best option for long duration and low-cost energy storage.
Sparton’s interest in the flow battery industry is a 9.975% interest in VRB Energy Inc. held through Sparton’s 90% interest in VanSpar Mining Inc. Full information regarding the history of the Company’s VRB Energy investment is available in its various news releases and corporate filings available at www.sedar.com, and on the Sparton website at www.spartonresources.com.
DOE Report
On August 16, 2024, The US Department of Energy’s (DOE’s) Office of Electricity, published a comprehensive report on different options for long-duration energy storage (LDES) costs, with flow batteries having been shown to the best rate between costs and performance.
The 51-page document (Achieving the Promise of Low-Cost Long Duration Energy Storage) contains cost comparisons between 10 LDES technologies, from electrochemical energy storage to chemical energy storage, mechanical energy storage and thermal energy storage.
The 10 LDES evaluated included: Flow batteries (FB), lithium-ion batteries (LIB), lead-acid batteries (PbA), hydrogen storage, sodium-ion batteries (NAIB), electro-chemical double layer capacitors (Supercapacitors/EDLC), zinc batteries, compressed air storages (CAES), pumped storage hydropower (PSH) and molten salt storage (TES).
Flow batteries were shown to have the best rate between costs and performance according to today’s technological status, as low as $0.06/kWh, which is close to DOE’s $0.05/kWh target. Lithium-ion batteries hold the second place with $0.07/kWh, followed by zinc battery varieties, e.g. ZnMnO2, with $0.08/kWh followed by the first ever rechargeable battery, the lead-acid battery with $0.09/kWh.
Sodium-ion batteries are still in an early stage with $0.26/kWh, but their commercial potential is high, when new electrolytes and even anodeless batteries are developed, according to the report. Supercapacitors suffer from low energy density and high self-discharge rates. From a cost-point perspective, they are expensive, at $0.34/kWh.
The DOE established the “Long Duration Storage Shot” protocol in 2021, evaluating various energy storage technologies to achieve 90% cost reduction by 2030 for technologies providing 10+ hours duration of energy storage.
It has also evaluated the top three potential innovations for each technology’s potential to reach the $0.05 level and also the costs for R&D for the next 10 years. The R&D range stretches from $90 million for supercapacitors to $1 billion for lithium-ion batteries.
On average, the top 10% of innovation portfolios can reduce LCOS by 12–85% to $0.03/kWh–$0.26/kWh across storage technologies, the report stated. New materials, electrolytes, membranes and other components must be ramped up quickly to production to achieve critical mass and to reduce overall system costs targets. Standardisation is recommended as a key element to reducing development and deployment costs for lead-acid, flow and zinc batteries.
The DOE did not address in detail the issues of safety and recyclability in its study. Both of these considerations clearly are very positive factors for the application of flow batteries over alternatives.
Source: Best Battery Briefing, Energy Storage Publishing Limited [email protected], August 19,2024.
Vanadium Redox Flow Batteries Safety
Flow batteries are recognized as the safest alternative for large-scale long-term energy storage. They are also fully recyclable.
UL 1973 is an internationally recognized global standard for commercially available battery energy storage.
VRB Energy has received the UL 1973 safety certificate for the Gen3 VRB-ESS®”, a major achievement, as it is the only battery system currently available that is certified at the UL 1973 Standard for its 1-Megawatt Hour power module. This unit is the basic VRB Energy building block.
About UL 1973
The UL 1973 certificate addresses major battery issues such as safety, reliability and operating uses. Included in this certification are testing protocols involving materials, vibration tests, high temperature operation, over charging, short circuiting, and physical drop tests.
The work was undertaken by VRB Energy with the CSA Group, formerly the Canadian Standards Association and the safety testing done using the International Organization for Standardization (“ISO”) protocols 13849-1, and 13849-2 2012 standards.